Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop in Wurtsboro

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop in Wurtsboro
4.5 / 5
50 reviews

Wurtsboto Plz, Wurtsboro, NY 12790, Wurtsboro

Overview

Cuisine
  • Italian
  • Pizza

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Do they deliver

No they don't do deliveries

Do they deliver?

Yes

Do you deliver?

Someone tell Cindy they do NOT deliver

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
MC
Melique Combs
google
11.24.2024
2/5

Usually good food but today it was all overcooked, burnt, and dried out....and I spent over $100 on my order.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
CC
Carl Clark
google
09.23.2018
5/5

Great place,people who run the place are very nice and the food is great

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
KB
Kayden Blake
google
09.21.2018
5/5

Tried this spot before with my friend and I am hooked since then. I enjoyed the good atmosphere and tasty dishes and drinks. Keep up the good work.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
ES
Eileen Salazar
google
09.13.2018
5/5

We went there last night to try it. (Actually, never knew it was there). They told us 35 min wait. Because of covid, we were waiting in the car with a hungry child that was getting upset. They got the food out to us in half the time, which was very much appreciated. Very good pizza. Could have used more pepperoni. The guy running the food out to the cars was running his butt off. We tipped him, and it seemed no one else was tipping the guy. Tip your server, people.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
GP
Gianni Parisi
google
09.09.2018
1/5

This is the WORST!!! place to go if your in the mood for pizza. Take the drive to Bloomingburg or drive to monticello & go to colosseo's pizza 2 LG pies for $20.00 I would rather buy a FROZEN PIZZA from Stewart's then put another dollar in that DIVE!!

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
BV
Barbara Vanhouten
google
09.09.2018
5/5

Very good food n very pleasant to go into. They do get to know you n they do remember your name.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
PR
Paul Roberts
google
08.14.2018
4/5

Good food. Sometimes a little off in timing. It's worth the wait.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
KO
Kerin O'Brien
google
08.13.2018
5/5

Such scrumptious pizza!!! Great sauce and crust, just a little pricey when you get toppings - if they put a little more toppings on it would definitely be worth it. 5 stars because I saw their ratings and feel they definitely deserve higher than they have on Google 😉

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
TM
Travis Mettler
google
07.15.2018
4/5

Very good pizza. Also they keep drinks full stocked at all times and have very timely pick up. Wish they delivered.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
AW
Al Wilson
google
06.05.2018
5/5

Best pizza around

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
BP
Barbara Pakosz
google
06.02.2018
5/5

Best pizza, friendly staff.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
AS
Ann Stephens
google
05.27.2018
1/5

Placed an order i was told it would take an hour. When I arrived to pick it up they clearly messed up the order I was on the phone when the staff was talking about me. When another person picked up the phone when I explained that i coukd hear the staff talking about me and how unprofessional it was i was told I could take my business else where . Which is what i did u went to Danny's which is a better pizza place anyway

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
pc
patrick cannon
google
05.27.2018
4/5

This is possibly the best pizza north of NYC. My taste may differ from some peoples but I think I know pizza. This is good stuff.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
BR
Beth Reulbach
google
05.08.2018
5/5

Awesome pizza! Seriously some of the best pizza I've ever had. Definitely recommended

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
VG
Vito Gasparre
google
05.05.2018
5/5

I was up for closing on my house in wurtsburo this pizza is A-1 and should be considered before all other's

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
sh
steven hard
google
03.25.2018
5/5

You gotta try the Momma slice.it's to die for..The Sicilan is the best around Yummy. ...

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
ooflaboola
google
03.08.2018
5/5

The pizza taste like a New York slice it’s never burnt the dough is very nice the sauce is very nice everything is amazing the garlic Knots are very good they have good sauce for them and they add a lot of garlic which makes taste good

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
PO
Priscilla Olcott
google
02.24.2018
1/5

Constantly messing up orders and are incredibly rude!!!Ordered wings last week medium which we have ordered for years and they were so hot my daughter refused to eat afterwards.This week I figured I would give it one more try so I ordered mild but when I got home,the wings were beyond well done and literally had zero sauce.I called and explained that the wings were so over cooked that my dog refused to eat the chicken when I pulled it off the bone and the lady owner got incredibly nasty,so I told her to go f herself..Danny Restaurant it is from here on out!

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
JB
John Barrack
google
02.15.2018
5/5

Best food and service. Very friendly people, we do luv it

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
Will
google
02.12.2018
5/5

Best pizza around. Specialty slices are the best I've had. Carbonara,chicken bacon ranch, cordon blu and marsala slices are all outstanding

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
MD
Marion Deluzio
google
02.12.2018
5/5

I absolutely love this family pizza place.From there anti pasta to there specialty pizza.So friendly great service. So many smiling faces. Your treated like your a part of their family.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
TD
Terence Duncan
google
02.10.2018
4/5

Great food

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
JJ
Jozef Javorsky
google
01.27.2018
5/5

Best pizza on East coast & Central Europe. The Italians should get there and learn how to make pizza. Well organized fast service & delicious food.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
MD
Malcolm Diaz
google
10.12.2017
5/5

Gotta Luv It has quietly become one of the best places wr go for food. The service and the staff are great but they actually pale in comparison to the food they pump out. It is truly that good!

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
AT
Alex Trager
google
09.09.2017
5/5

I'm a bit of a stickler for a good slice of pizza and hoo wee, this place lives up to its name. I tend to judge pizza places by their barbecue chicken slice and these guys set a new standard for me! Any time I'm in the area I stop by, and it's always a pleasure.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
SS
Spooky Scarey Skeleton
google
08.24.2017
4/5

Plain pizza and Italian combos are their best. Everything else is meh.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
TD
Tyler Durdin
google
08.02.2017
5/5

Great owners and staff.... excellent food.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
ML
Mia Lee
google
06.19.2017
5/5

literally the best pizza I ever had!! 🍕 😍

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
princessbambi21
google
06.16.2017
5/5

Quick service. Amazing selection. Delicious pizza. Best pizza of my life.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
GE
Garry Engelberg
google
05.18.2017
5/5

Excellent pizza in the middle of nowhere

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
JD
Joe Donovan
google
05.16.2017
5/5

Very thankful for this place. Excellent food and service.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
SE
Simone E
google
04.03.2017
5/5

Owner and staff are always super friendly, helpful, and overall good people. Great pizza, plus you feel good about supporting a small local business. Best pizza in the county!

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
TM
Taryn Mullahy
google
03.26.2017
5/5

Abraham and his wife are amazing human beings. This pizzeria is so well run with wonderful food. They are incredibly kind and accommodating people and are always looking to help feed the community. Abraham helped to feed a family in need and truly pays it forward. What a fantastic establishment! Thank you for delivering high quality food and service during such uncertain times!

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
CW
Cindy Winfield
google
02.02.2017
5/5

Amazing food very delicious

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
JM
Jessica Mcdevitt
google
10.23.2016
5/5

Always fast and friendly. I love stopping there before I go to work. There specialty pizza is amazing and I love the crust.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
JH
James Hatigan
google
10.17.2016
5/5

The best pizza in the county

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
FM
Fred Mccarty
google
10.14.2016
5/5

Always enjoy the food. People are nice. Last pizza from there was especially good.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
JW
Jeff Walter
google
10.01.2016
5/5

Every time I find myself in the vicinity of this establishment, I always make it a point to stop in period the food is of superb quality and the prices are very competitive and quite reasonable. The service provided by the staff is exceptional and the pride they take In the product they serve is exemplary. Everyone from the owner, managment to the general staff will make you feel that you are amongst long time friends. When you stop in, ask for a "Mama Pie." Food so good, your tongue will slap your brain 😋

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
MM
Mykel Moody
google
10.01.2016
5/5

I love this place. GottaLuvit Indeed! The staff is the best ; Friendly, Professional, and Delioues.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
TM
Tracey M
google
09.09.2016
5/5

Excellent family pizzeria. Prices are fair. Food is always fresh and they have a great menu with plenty of variety.

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
JS
Joe Staff
google
08.23.2016
5/5

Best pizza in my area

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
WS
William Semonite
google
08.13.2016
4/5

Excellent food excellent service

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
cw
christina wilkins
google
07.19.2016
5/5

I have been a loyal customer for years and I have never been let down. The staff is awesome and their food is always on point!

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
HM
Harold Mota
google
05.25.2016
5/5

Gatta Love It! Definitely worth the drive! The crust to sauce ratio was perfect. The pizza was cooked to perfection. I had a marvelous meal. Thank you!

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
ts
thomas schuler
google
05.22.2016
4/5

Great food and prompt service

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
JG
Julius Greenberg
google
05.19.2016
5/5

Great food at a reasonable price. Worth going there

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
IH
Irving Hamilton
google
05.18.2016
5/5

The best of everthing

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
KO
Krista Outwater
google
05.16.2016
5/5

The owner is exceptional. Very friendly place with very good food. If only they still delivered!

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
BW
Brett Wright
google
02.23.2016
2/5

Overpriced n not very flavorful. Put lotsa lettuce on a sub but not much of anything else. Not very happy. Been 3x spaced well apart. Dont think I will give them a 4th 😔

Gotta Luv IT Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop
GI
Gloria Itzkowitz
google
01.14.2016
4/5

Pleasant service, good food. Gotten tasty stuff from here twice so far in our short time here. And a parking lot!

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 18458884222

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!